100 Greatest GHSA Finals

In 2023, GHSF Daily counted down the 100 Greatest Football Finals in GHSA history, adding a new game each weekday through Dec. 8, when the No. 1 championship game of all time was revealed. The 100 games were ranked on entertainment value and historical significance. Upsets, comebacks and lead changes were naturally favored, but memorable players, teams or incidents might also make a game special. To help quantify some of those criteria, GHSF Daily recruited Loren Maxwell and his computer Maxwell Ratings to calculate the pregame point spread, or line, by analyzing the scores of every regular-season and playoff game played since 1947. The 100 Greatest is the culmination of more than two years of researching the 369 GHSA finals played from 1947 to 2022.

 

 

No. 1: Bainbridge 47, Warner Robins 41 (3OT) (2018 Class 5A)

Line: Warner Robins -15 (85% chance of winning). Fifteen scoring plays, three overtimes and one giant upset. Warner Robins had beaten Bainbridge 38-0 in the regular season. Apparently seeking commensurate retribution, Bainbridge bolted to a shocking 21-0 lead at Mercedes-Benz Stadium, scoring on a punt return, an interception return and a halfback pass in 90 seconds late in the first quarter. Bainbridge returned another interception for a touchdown in the third quarter for a 35-7 edge. It wouldn’t be enough. Spurred by Class 5A offensive player of the year Dylan Fromm, Warner Robins scored the next 28 points and had a chance to win on the final play of regulation, but Bainbridge’s Roman Harrison, a defensive end committed to Tennessee, blocked a 27-yard field goal attempt. It took three extra periods to decide it, and the second overtime proved pivotal. Warner Robins made a 20-yard field goal but surprisingly did not accept a roughing-the-kicker penalty that would’ve given the Demons a first-and-goal at the 2. Warner Robins coach Mike Chastain said later that an official mistakenly told him it would be fourth down at the 2, prompting his decision to take the points and decline the penalty. Warner Robins then held Bainbridge to a field goal to send the game to a third overtime. Bainbridge went ahead on quarterback Quayde Hawkins' 7-yard option keeper. The Bearcats failed the two-point try, which was mandatory after two overtimes, but it wouldn’t matter. Warner Robins had a second-and-2 from the Bainbridge 7 when the Bearcats’ Harrison stuffed an inside run for a loss. Tahari Tate then nailed Fromm for a sack. On fourth-and-10 from the 15, Fromm had another chance but threw incomplete to a well-covered receiver in a corner of the end zone, ending the Demons' bid. This was the longest game in state finals history as measured by overtimes (three) and time (3 hours, 50 minutes). It is the only state final in which both teams scored more than 40 points. Warner Robins’ 28-point comeback is a state finals record achieved in vain. According to the Maxwell Ratings’ retroactive calculations, the -14.6 point spread is the third-largest for a winning underdog behind 2015 Westminster’s -15.3 against Blessed Trinity and 2018 Milton’s -19 against Colquitt County. The championship was Bainbridge’s second, first since 1982. The Bearcats became the third team in GHSA history to win a title after a .500 regular season or worse, joining 1965 West Rome and 1992 Thomas County Central.

No. 2: LaGrange 17, Colquitt County 16 (1991 Class 4A)

Line: LaGrange -5 (67% chance of winning). In a victory that gave LaGrange the USA Today national title, Scott Simons kicked a 24-yard field goal with 13 seconds left at the end of an 83-yard drive that survived a do-or-die fourth-and-11. LaGrange entered 14-0 and ranked No. 2 in USA Today. The No. 1 team, Rialto of California, had lost the previous day. The Grangers were tempting the same bad ending. Colquitt County was a three-loss team that had won four road playoff games to make the final but playing on its home field for the championship. Colquitt took a 16-14 lead on Sharone Roberts’ 27-yard run with 6:37 left in the third quarter. Walter Harris, a future NFL Pro Bowler, blocked the extra point, which would come in handy in the end. Colquitt County was driving for the knockout blow midway in the fourth quarter, but Harris intercepted a pass at the LaGrange 10. Rodney Hudson, the AJC’s all-classification player of the year, then drove the Grangers into field-goal position, completing four of six passes for 61 yards and scrambling for 14 yards, accounting for 75 of the 83 yards. The fourth-and-11 conversion might’ve been the greatest single play in LaGrange football history, which has seen five state titles. Wrote AJC reporter Matt Winkeljohn, “After taking the snap, Hudson stepped back, scrambled forward, then left, then right, then left, then right and threw a pass that [Russ] Davidson caught with Patrick Mansfield right on top of him, swiping at the ball the whole time.” This is the only GHSA final in the highest classification that featured four lead changes. The game’s score progression was 7-0, 7-7, 7-10, 14-10, 14-16, 17-16.

No. 3: Grayson 23, Roswell 20 (OT) (2016 Class 7A)

Line: Grayson -8 (71% chance of winning). It was the most star-studded championship game in state history. Roswell had nine seniors who would sign with Power 5 Conference teams. Grayson had eight. Roswell quarterback Malik Willis and safety Xavier McKinney, now in the NFL, had led the Hornets to a 14-0 record and the No. 2 state ranking. But Grayson – 13-1 and ranked No. 1 – was the favorite. The Rams’ only loss came against Florida-based football factory IMG Academy in the opener. Grayson had multiple top-five national rankings. They also had four transfers from fellow Gwinnett County schools, each an ESPN 300 player, making Grayson a controversial if not villainous team to its rivals. The game lived up to its billing. Grayson managed just 71 yards over the first three quarters but took its first lead, 20-13, with 1:04 remaining in regulation when Chase Brice threw a 35-yard TD pass to Jaquavius Lane. The pair then hooked up for a critical two-point conversion pass. Five minutes earlier, Brice had hit Lane for a 62-yard TD pass to get Grayson within 13-12, but the extra point was blocked. Now trailing by seven with 64 seconds left, Roswell showed its mettle, driving 70 yards on seven plays. On the final play of regulation, Willis hit Kentrell Barber with a 20-yard TD pass. In overtime, Grayson’s Will VanPamelen made a 25-yarder for a 23-20 lead. Roswell’s Turner Barckhoff, who had been good from 47 and 29 yards earlier in the game, missed from 32. That was the final play of the last high school game in the Georgia Dome, home of the GHSA finals from 2008 to 2016. Grayson finished No. 4 in MaxPreps’ Xcellent national rankings. Roswell was No. 11. Grayson’s Jeff Herron became the first coach in history to win state titles at three Georgia schools (Oconee County and Camden County were the others). He also became the first to spend exactly one season as a coach, win a state title, and depart. In February, he took a job at T.L. Hanna in South Carolina.

No. 4: Thomas County Central 14, Thomasville 12 (1993 Class 3A)

Line: Thomas County Central -1 (55% chance of winning). They are crosstown rivals, just 3.5 miles apart. The game was played at Thomas County Central’s Jacket Stadium, packed with 11,500 fans. Those without seats were allowed on the sidelines and behind the end zones. No legal spot of grass went unclaimed. The goal-line stand they witnessed was one for the ages. Training 14-10 with 7:37 left, Thomasville set forth on a drive from Central’s 35. On 10 plays, the Bulldogs arrived first-and-goal at the 5. Thomasville’s Danny Jones, who played at Central the season before, ran to the 1. Nic Davis then charged into Central’s line. Thomasville quarterback Kevin Thompson signaled touchdown. Many Thomasville fans believe he got his torso and the ball over the goal line, but officials placed the ball two inches short. On third down, Central pushed Thomasville back almost to the 2 (see Thomasville’s third-and-inches play at the 25:00 mark). After a timeout, Thomasville tried again. Jones took an option pitchout. It never had a chance. Central coach Ed Pilcher gambled that Thomasville would run the play, and his players keyed on it. Central cornerback Corey Clark tackled Jones for a 4-yard loss with 2:03 left. Central took a safety on a punt with 7 seconds left, effectively ending it. Three seasons before, the GHSA expanded the state playoffs to 16 teams in each class, making it possible for archrivals from the same region or city to meet up for the championship. This was the first of its kind, and still the best.

No. 5: Athens 26, Valdosta 26 (1969 Class 3A)

Line: Valdosta -14 (90% chance of winning). Electing to receive, Athens took the opening kickoff and drove 81 yards in six plays, becoming only the second team to score on Valdosta that season and the first to lead the Wildcats in more than two years. A reigning national champion with a 12-0 record and 11 shutouts, Valdosta was just that good, especially at Cleveland Field, where it hadn’t lost a playoff game since 1950. And the game’s rousing start – with Athens star Andy Johnson leading the charge – soon was superseded by what happened in the middle and the end. On the last play of the first half, Johnson took off on a 68-yard TD run. Nonetheless, Valdosta overcame those insults and led 26-18 in the closing minutes. With 1:10 left, the ’Cats lost a fumble at the Athens 26. Athens coach Weyman Sellers called on a trick play on third-and-7, and Johnson hit Gary Travis on a tackle-eligible for 43 yards to the Valdosta 28. On the next play, Sellers tried his luck again, this time to the other side to tackle Rand Lambert, who was wide open for a 28-yard touchdown with 25 seconds remaining. This was the first season that two-point conversions were legal. Johnson passed to Gray Sellers, the coach’s son, who made a leaping catch in the end zone for the tie, leaving the teams as co-champions, tied 26-26. Johnson finished with 109 yards rushing and 156 passing. He went on to star at Georgia and played seven seasons in the NFL. Given a 9.7% chance to beat Valdosta in the Maxwell Ratings’ retroactive odds, Athens is the second-most unlikely champion of all time behind 2018 Milton.

No. 6: Westminster 38, Blessed Trinity 31 (2015 Class 3A)

Line: Blessed Trinity -15 (87% chance of winning). Judged by Maxwell’s point spreads, Westminster’s victory was the biggest upset in state finals history to that point, surpassed later only by Milton’s 2018 win over Colquitt County. Westminster became the first team to win a state title after trailing by 15 points in the fourth quarter. That’s still the standard. Blessed Trinity had beaten the Wildcats 24-10 two months earlier, and Westminster found itself down 24-9 to start the period and 31-17 with 6:25 left but scored two touchdowns in regulation and another in overtime to pull it out. The first fourth-quarter score came at the end of an 11-play, 80-yard drive. Then with 3:37 left, Westminster's Watson Jackson recovered an onside kick at the Blessed Trinity 21. Westminster scored a play later on Zay Malcome’s 21-yard run for the tie. Malcome scored again in overtime. The game ended when Milton Shelton – a two-way starter who rushed for 254 yards on 37 carries – lost a fumble into the end zone after a 9-yard gain. Westminster’s Blake Gillikin, now in the NFL with the New Orleans Saints, made field goals of 32, 53 and 21 yards, was 6-for-6 on touchbacks and punted three times for a 61.7-yard average, putting two inside the 20-yard line. And he executed the critical onside kick. In claiming its first title since 1978, Westminster became the first team to win five playoff games away from home in one postseason. The last one came in the Georgia Dome, nine miles from campus.

No. 7: Lanier (Macon) 15, Marist 14 (1948 Class 2A)

Line: Marist -7 (77% chance of winning). One wonders why the GHSA would allow ties and co-champions to exist for nearly six decades. This would help explain it. For the second consecutive season, the Class 2A final was tied after regulation. The year before, in 1947, Lanier beat Richmond Academy 7-6 on the GHSA’s penetration rule, getting its seventh point because the Poets had the most penetrations inside their opponent’s 30-yard line. In 1948, Lanier and Marist were tied 13-13 late in the fourth quarter. Marist, located in Midtown Atlanta in those days and known as the Cadets, probably would’ve won with just one more first down, or perhaps simply by taking a knee. Instead, Lanier forced and recovered a fumble at midfield and drove to inside the 3-yard line in the final minute as Marist’s Chappell Rhino made a TD-saving tackle. Lanier then struck at Marist’s goal four times. The Poets got no farther than the 1, and the game ended. Marist’s Shorty Doyal, the most famous Georgia high school football coach of his day, believed Marist had won with this epic goal-line stand as Marist led 6-3 in penetrations. But the GHSA had changed its rules that offseason, adding two more tiebreaker points – one for most total yards, one for most first downs. Claiming this was the first he’d heard of it, Doyal was “indignant,” the Atlanta Journal reported. Doyal and Lanier coach Selby Buck rushed to the press box to hover over nervous statisticians, who counted and re-counted the yards and first downs. A crowd of more than 8,000 at Atlanta’s Grady Stadium waited 30 minutes for the verdict. Penetrations went to Marist, 6-3. First downs went to Lanier, 10-6. Total yards went to ... Lanier, 225-212. The Poets were awarded the victory, 15-14. Doyal protested the outcome to the GHSA but lost, as the tiebreaker was spelled out in the GHSA’s new bylaws, but the controversy ultimately persuaded the GHSA to let ties stand starting in 1949. The new rule endured 58 years through nine ties and 18 co-champions. Lanier would remain a state power for three more decades but wouldn’t win another state title. The Macon school closed in 1970. Marist – so dependent on Doyal that it didn’t field a varsity team the season after he retired in 1953 – would lose in five more state finals before breaking through in 1989 under coach Alan Chadwick. Lanier and Marist entered the 1948 championship game undefeated. They played each other in the regular season. Naturally, they tied, 7-7.

No. 8: North Gwinnett 19, Colquitt County 17 (2017 Class 7A)

Line: North Gwinnett -5 (64% chance of winning). North Gwinnett won its first state title in its 57th season of football with the strangest and most desperate last-minute drive in state finals history. The Bulldogs took a 16-10 lead midway through the fourth quarter on Cameron Butler's 1-yard run. Colquitt County answered with a 12-play, five-minute drive capped by Steven Krajewski's 13-yard touchdown pass to Josh Hadley for a 17-16 lead with 49 seconds remaining. North Gwinnett then scurried 59 yards – 35 on four Colquitt County penalties – and lined up for a 38-yard field goal on an untimed final play to end the game. Cameron Clark, who had missed an extra point that left North Gwinnett trailing 17-16, calmly kicked it through for the win. It remains the only winning points scored on the final play of a regulation game in finals history. Colquitt County had won four straight playoff road games as a No. 3 seed to reach the finals. The championship game would’ve been in neutral Mercedes-Benz Stadium, but a snowstorm postponed the game a week, and it was played at North Gwinnett, the higher seed.

No. 9: Buford 34, Lee County 31 (OT) (2020 Class 6A)

Line: Tossup. Trailing 31-24 with 1:58 left, Buford drove 65 yards in nine plays to send the game to overtime, kicked a field goal on its OT possession and forced and recovered a fumble at the 3-yard line to win at Georgia State’s Center Parc Stadium. Lee County had a first-and-goal at the 4 on the final play, but star RB Caleb McDowell, who would sign with South Carolina, was stripped of the ball by Buford safety Jake Pope, who would sign with Alabama. Defensive tackle River Wilson recovered, ending the game. Buford’s winning field goal, a 26-yarder, was made by Alejandro Mata, who had been Lee County’s JV kicker two seasons prior. Buford’s tying touchdown was a 16-yard pass from Ashton Daniels to future Alabama WR Isaiah Bond, who also had a 53-yard TD reception in the first half. Daniels, who would sign in 2022 with Stanford, had led a game-winning drive the previous season in the finals to beat Warner Robins. He came off the bench both times and was 17-of-22 passing for 192 yards in this one. Lee County entered ranked No. 1. Buford was No. 2. Lee County led in total yards 398-390. This game’s seven lead changes or ties are the second-most in state finals history. The record is eight (2016 ELCA vs. Fellowship Christian). The state title was Buford’s 13th.

No. 10: Calhoun 27, Buford 24 (OT) (2011 Class 2A)

Line: Buford -13 (82% chance of winning). Calhoun found sweet redemption in the Georgia Dome after losing three consecutive finals to Buford and won its first state title since 1952. Calhoun let a 24-10 lead get away in the final two minutes but rediscovered itself in overtime to deny Buford of what would’ve been the Wolves’ fifth straight title. It was the fifth-biggest upset in state finals history – Buford was on a 72-2 run – based on the Maxwell Ratings’ projected margin of victory. Trailing by 14, the No. 1-ranked Wolves cut No. 2 Calhoun’s lead to 24-17 on Sam Clay’s 24-yard TD pass to Paris Head. Buford failed to recover an onside kick but called three timeouts to save time for a Calhoun punt. The snap was misplayed, and Buford’s Dillon Lee would recover it and run 40 yards to tie the game with 39 seconds left. In overtime, Buford lost a fumble on its first play when Calhoun’s Hunter Knight made a hit on Buford's Andre Johnson. Calhoun elected to try the winning field goal on first down, and Adam Griffith, who would go on to kick at Alabama, was good from 32 yards. He had made field goals of 46 and 37 yards in the fourth quarter. Calhoun’s Taylor Lamb, nephew of coach Hal Lamb, was 16-of-34 passing for 196 yards and rushed for 73 yards, accounting for 89% of his team’s total yards. Hal Lamb became the fifth man to win GHSA state championships as player and head coach. He played on Commerce's 1981 championship team. Lamb and Ray Lamb (1965-66 Warren County, 1981 Commerce) were the second father and son to win Georgia state championships as coaches. The first to do it were Chip Walker (2009-10 Sandy Creek) and Rodney Walker (1984 West Rome).

No. 11: Washington County 22, Americus 21 (1996 Class 2A)

Line: Washington County -5 (65% chance of winning). In a game between 14-0 teams ranked No. 1 and No. 2, Washington County became the first team in state finals history to rally from a 21-point deficit to win and scored the winning points on a trick play. No other state champion has rallied from more than 15 points down. This game was getting late when Americus, the home team, took a 21-0 lead on Fabian Walker’s 5-yard pass to John Wilson midway in the third quarter. Walker was 6-for-6 passing for 75 yards on the drive. A sophomore, Walker was playing his first season of organized football. He’d go on to become Georgia’s all-time leading passer, the first to surpass 8,000 career yards. Walker later threw a 45-yard TD pass to Wilson, who had 1,257 yards receiving that season, the most in Georgia in 25 years. He was the Associated Press all-class state player of the year. Americus got its other touchdown when Kris Simpson intercepted a highly pressured Terrence Edwards in Washington County’s end zone. But Edwards, a junior, would have the last word. He drove his team 87 yards and scored on a 29-yard scramble to cut the lead to 21-7 with 1:25 left in the third. Americus fumbled the ensuing kickoff, and Reid Bethea recovered. Washington County scored in five plays, Edwards scoring from the 4, making it 21-14 with 11:53 left. After an Americus three-and-out, Washington County and Edwards went to work again, going 69 yards on eight pays. Edwards hit Keith Reeves with a 14-yard TD pass with 6:55 left. Edwards lined up to hold for the extra point, his usual role, but this time, he took the snap and ran with it, going around left end untouched for a 22-21 lead. Americus hadn’t threatened since the middle of the third quarter and would not again.

No. 12: Greenville 12, Clinch County 10 (1980 Class A)

Line: Greenville -10 (83% chance of winning). Call it the “Hail Mary” game. “With no timeouts, we just had to throw it up and pray,” Greenville’s Dwight Hochstetler said. What led up to the greatest ending in state finals history made the moment only more improbable. Clinch County took a 10-0 lead on a field goal with 10:43 left. Only two teams had come back from 10-point deficits in the fourth quarter to win state championships (1949 Decatur, 1952 Calhoun), and neither of those trailed by so much inside of three minutes to go. Greenville finally hit paydirt on Kenneth Bolton’s 5-yard TD pass to Darryl Ogletree with 2:15 remaining to make it 10-6. Greenville got the ball back at its 17 with 1:24 left but had no timeouts. Ogletree – who rushed for 165 yards in the game, 2,585 on the season – threw a halfback pass to tight end Melvin Robertson for 36 yards to Clinch County’s 42. With the clock rolling under 20 seconds, Greenville rushed to the line and tried the play again, this time with Robertson in the end zone. According to the AJC, two Clinch County defenders tipped the ball, but Robertson caught it on his back for the score with 10 seconds left. It would be hard to argue against that being the greatest single play in state finals history. Greenville, in its fourth varsity season, had its first state title.

No. 13: Milton 14, Colquitt County 13 (2018 Class 7A)

Line: Colquitt County -19 (91% chance of winning). Milton pulled off what the Maxwell Ratings compute as the biggest upset in state finals history. Colquitt County was 14-0 and ranked No. 1 in Class 7A while holding several top-five national rankings, one as high as No. 2. The Packers had won state titles in 2014 and 2015, and through the semifinals, this had been the most dominant team in program history. In the game played at Mercedes-Benz Stadium, Milton’s Josh Edwards scored on an 11-yard run on a fourth-and-1 play with 11:47 left for a 14-10 lead. Colquitt later drove 45 yards and had a first-and-goal at the Milton 10 but settled for a 24-yard field goal by all-state kicker Ryan Fitzgerald. Colquitt had one more possession but failed to cross midfield. Both teams had 34-yard field-goal attempts blocked in the second quarter. Colquitt was held to 239 yards of total offense. Milton linebacker Jordan Davis had three tackles for 16 yards in losses. Milton, at No. 8, was the lowest-ranked team ever to beat a No. 1-ranked team in the finals of the highest class. It was the first state title for Milton, which began varsity football in 1950. Milton, a north Fulton County school, was the first school outside of Gwinnett County or Region 1 to win a state-title game in the highest class since Southwest DeKalb in 1995. (Roswell of Fulton shared a state title in 2006 when it tied Peachtree Ridge.) In preseason, Milton's odds of winning the state title given its football history were 1,073-to-1, according to the Maxwell Ratings. This would be the final Colquitt County game for coach Rush Propst, who would be fired in March for a variety of alleged misconduct that he denied.

No. 14: Mill Creek 70, Carrollton 35 (2022 Class 7A)

Line: Mill Creek -1 (56.6% chance of winning). With nearly two minutes left until halftime and Mill Creek leading 48-28, it was already the eighth-highest-scoring game in GHSA finals history. It would finish on top with 14 points to spare. During one astounding 55-second stretch in the first quarter, the teams scored five touchdowns. Not done yet, they scored two more within 14 seconds of each other early in the second quarter. Until this game, there had been only 60 scoring plays of 80 yards or longer in finals history. These teams did it five times in 3 minutes, 30 seconds across the first and second quarters. Special teams got into the act, too, as Mill Creek became the first team in finals history to return a blocked field goal for a touchdown (Jamal Anderson 88 yards) and the second, first since 2009 Camden County, to score two special-teams touchdowns in a final (Anderson’s score plus Makhail Wood 96-yard kickoff return). Mill Creek never trailed and ended all doubt with a nine-play, 80-yard TD drive after Carrollton had gotten within 49-35 in the third quarter. Mill Creek’s Cam Robinson rushed for 252 yards, the most in finals history for a player in the highest class. Carrollton’s Julian “Ju Ju” Lewis, a freshman, passed for a state-finals record 531 yards. Mill Creek’s Caleb Downs, who would sign with Alabama as the state’s consensus No. 1 recruit and become the unanimous state player of the year, scored touchdowns on three short runs. Mill Creek finished with 597 yards. Carrollton had 531. It was Mill Creek’s first state title.

No. 15: Southwest Atlanta 21, Americus 7 (1973 Class 2A)

Line: Tossup. Southwest became the first all-African American team to win a GHSA championship in a game far more suspenseful than its score. After three scoreless quarters, Americus took a 7-0 lead with 10:07 left on John Jordan’s 11-yard pass to Charlie Austin. With about six minutes left, Americus lined up at the Southwest 1-yard line, poised to finish it before its home crowd. But Kent Mason, a linebacker, redirected momentum, to put it lightly, when he intercepted in the end zone and returned it more than 100 yards to the Americus 1. Quarterback Tony Flanagan, the Class 2A Back of the Year, scored a play later. There was a bad snap on the extra point, but holder Gerald Glover retrieved it and threw to Flanagan for two points and an 8-7 lead with 5:35 left. From there, Americus disintegrated. Southwest intercepted two more passes over 3½ minutes, the first at the Americus 5 and leading to another short Flanagan TD run, the last one returned 51 yards by Randy Smith for a 21-7 lead. Flanagan passed for more than 2,000 yards that season, a rare feat in those days, and his 30 TD passes were a state record. He would lead Southwest’s basketball team to a state title that winter. He went on to play both sports at Georgia, where he became the school’s first African American to play quarterback. Mason and defensive end Reggie Wilkes played at Georgia Tech and in the NFL as tackles. No Atlanta Public Schools football team has won a state title, or been so revered, since this one.